In Reading Lolita in Tehran: A Memoir in Books, Azar Nafisi (the author) weaves her personal life in Iran with Western fiction to not only illustrate the power of literature but also to create a metaphor that represents the imposition of the Islamic Republic's ideology. However, is this image of Iran too relentless? Does it accurately portray the country's circumstances? Fatemah Keshavarz, author of Jasmine and Stars: Reading More Than Lolita in Tehran, shares with her readers fond memories of her father, her uncle, her mother, and their intimate connection with literature to remedy Nafisi's contemptuous tone. In addition, Keshavarz devotes a chapter for her criticisms on the Nafisi's portrayal of 'ordinary' Iranians as either extremists or helpless victims, the erasure of the intermediaries, and factual errors that seem prevalent throughout Reading Lolita in Tehran.
The Rogerian essay below will cover a little more about their backstories and justifications for their views:








