Quackery in Medicine: An Introduction

mvenus929's picture

I am a big proponent for patients taking charge of their own health, becoming informed about their bodies rather than simply relying on authority figures to tell them what is going wrong. However, many people don't have the science background to really understand what is being told to them, and so they'll tend to rely on those authority figures regardless. While one of my goals as a (hopefully) future physician is to make sure my patients know what is going on and focus on preventative medicine, rather than treatment, I am going to start that a little early with this new series.

As more and more people turn towards 'natural' ways of healing themselves, there has developed a market aimed at meeting these desires. Countless remedies have popped up, and complementary and alternative medicines (CAM for short) has taken a foothold in American society. I have been interested in these treatments for some time, as I, too, have become uneasy with the trend in allopathic medicine to treat the symptoms of a disease, rather than the whole patient.

That being said, though, much contained in the field of CAM is pure quackery. It is either unfounded or goes completely against what we know about modern science. And while many of these treatments are harmless, several of them can be very dangerous. Informing the public about them is one of the only weapons we have against these treatments, though, since by nature they go unregulated by the FDA and other government organizations (though please, keep complaints about government regulation out of this series).

In another blog, I was asked to expose some of these more dangerous treatments. I haven't done much in the way of research for this series yet, but I plan to cover several of the well-known treatments. I haven't yet decided whether I should cover treatments proven to work, or only treatments proven not to work. I will cover a wide range of topics, though.

In some ways, I am asking for your help. If you have a question, feel free to post it here, and I will do my best to research and address the claims. To be fair, though, I should list my credentials now. As of present, I have a Bachelor of Science in Biology, with some additional training in the allied health careers. I am currently applying to medical school with the hopes of getting in. Should I gain admission to some school, I will begin basic science classes again next Fall (Fall 2010). If I continue this series after that point, the arguments expressed will likely have more scientific backing.

I look forward to starting this series, and hope that everyone can gain something from it.

sawaboof's picture
Volunteer for the Progressive U Alumni Association

Some CAM treatments are harmless, some are dangerous... and some actually do work to treat diseases, but have dangerous reactions to other medications... such as taking St. John's Wort for depression if you're also taking seizure or heart medications.

I'm a fan of alternative medicine, and enjoy aromatherapy a lot (if peppermint doesn't actually work on migraines, then it's a damn good placebo effect!), but when people without a medical background start self-diagnosing and self-treating based on what they read on the internet, it becomes just as dangerous as using someone else's prescription meds to avoid seeing the doctor.

I think part of the danger of using CAM treatments is that, when the doctor asks someone if they're on any other medications, most people don't consider the ginkgo balboa and fish oil and garlic they're taking "medications" and so they don't let the doctor know about them. And then they have adverse reactions to something the doctor prescribes because it interacts with what they're already taking. ALWAYS let your doctor know if you're trying out alternative medicine!


"What a crazy random happenstance!"
Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog

Read my Blog!

mvenus929's picture
Managing Director of Progressive U

Just to clarify... when I say that I believe patients should be informed, I don't mean that they should be informed to the point of self-diagnosing and self-treating. That may be ok for a simple cold, but if you believe something is wrong with you, go to the doctor and don't let him or her brush you off, and know WHY they are doing what they are doing. This morning, I walked into a room where there was a note that said I couldn't draw blood from either arm (we won't get into how stupid it is to order blood tests on someone who can't be drawn from either arm on). When I asked the patient why we couldn't, he didn't have a clue. That's the type of thing a patient should know about their own health.

~C
Check out the latest entry in the Between The Lines column!
Want the highest rated list to change? RATE those blogs, then!

sawaboof's picture
Volunteer for the Progressive U Alumni Association

No worries; that is not what I thought you meant by patients being informed. :P


"What a crazy random happenstance!"
Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog

Read my Blog!

bridge's picture
Volunteer for the Progressive U Alumni Association

Good mission for this blog series. I think it will be interesting to read, but also a necessity. We non-med students are hopelessly uninformed. I'll be the first to admit it.

One question: What is "allopathic medicine"? Now, I've learned in school to look at "context clues" in the sentence, so I'm assuming it's the average medication given out every day that's not considered alternative. Like Paxil and Claritin and every other pill with a commercial to its name...

Anyway, if that's the case, then I agree that they treat only the symptoms. And they have way too many negative side effects.

mvenus929's picture
Managing Director of Progressive U

Allopathic medicine is that headed by the MDs... medical schools that give out MD degrees are called allopathic, to contrast against schools who give out DO degrees (they are osteopathic schools).

~C
Check out the latest entry in the Between The Lines column!
Want the highest rated list to change? RATE those blogs, then!

bridge's picture
Volunteer for the Progressive U Alumni Association

Thanks for clearing that up. :)

kinkatia's picture
Member of the Progressive U Alumni Association

This makes me happy, and I intend to follow this blog series of yours. I've been finding myself wanting to know more and more about this topic since, in research for a novel I'm planning, I stumbled upon a book by some pharmacists in Germany who promote natural alternatives to chemical medications. It's an interesting book, and best of all, it explains what works for what, why it works, and pushes people to see their doctors and not self-diagnose if there's a possibility it's more than a cold. It made me realize how little I know about my own health care. I don't like that. I shall learn.

And that's comin' at ya' from yer local redneck hippie.
--
Ooh, ooh, pick me, pick me!!!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.