The word "psychotropic" is defined as "affecting mental activity, behavior, or perception, as a mood-altering drug." Basically, this isn't just taking an Tylenol if you've got a headache or Zyrtec for allergies. It's way more complex than that. These drugs get into your mind and start messing with the chemicals and electrical processes in there--processes that scientists, as confident as they are about a lot of things, don't fully understand. Essentially these are drugs that could change your personality. Honestly, I don't think people (or doctors, apparently) are giving this fact as much weight as it warrants when prescribing something for their hyperactive or mopey kid.
ADHD/ADD: Ritalin, Adderol, Concerta
So let's say you have a kid that's not doing well in school. He doesn't pay attention in class, he's constantly bouncing off the walls, he's totally out of control. So you take him to the doctor, and he's diagnosed with ADHD. He gets some pills for it--voila, he's a model student. Right?
I hear this story a lot among people I know. Usually it's about their little brother--in some cases it's about them. I would say roughly a third of the people I know (or indirectly know) either have been diagnosed with ADHD or have a family member diagnosed with it. In fact, according to this site, 5-12% of all children have ADHD.
I don't know about you, but I think that's absolutely NUTS.
My brother was diagnosed with ADHD a few years ago and had been taking medication for it since he was diagnosed. I'm pretty sure he's switch through several brands but right now I think he's on Concerta. He's been taking them so long that I can't really remember what he was like before he was taking them--but there is a distinct difference between his medicated and unmedicated personalities.
When he has taken his "pill", he's a zombie. He doesn't talk very much, he has no appetite, he doesn't get excited about things or laugh at jokes. He tells me that all he wants to do when he's taking his pill is write essays. He often isn't even interested in his main passion--video games. Considering that normally he would spend fourteen hours a day on his Xbox if he were allowed to, that's a pretty drastic change. I guess it's great if all he ever needed to do in life was take tests and write essays.
When he hasn't taken it (for whatever reason: we ran out, it's a holiday) he's totally different. He's cheerful and funny--he laughs at jokes, he smiles more and has the appetite of a whale shark. Overall he just gives off a totally different vibe--more lively and normal and--healthy, honestly. He might be a little unfocused, he might get bored a little more easily--but at least he's a human being. The problem, however, is that he is also prone to unpredictable mood swings--once he actually attacked me almost completely out of the blue with little provocation. My dad thinks it may have been a withdrawal symptom.
Withdrawal symptom? It was more like something a coke addict would do if you took away his stash.
In fact, this site states that ADHD medications are closely related to street drugs such as meth and cocaine.
I never keep my feelings about this a secret from my parents--I usually discuss it with them a lot, actually. But I understand that performing well in school is important and taking this medication may be the only means of ensuring that happens.
Nevertheless, I can't help but be secretly glad when he runs out of medication for a day or two. And I can't help but feel that doctors are far too quick to dole out what could be characterized as crack to kids.
I may add on to this blog or post a few more blogs about other psychotropic drugs such as antidepressants.




I believe that ADHD and ADD is real. I have seen many kids on the drug for ADHD and only two were normal while on the drug. One of the two kids could not sit still or stay on task he was put on the drug and became normal. He was able to hold a conversation and complete tasks. The other child had the focus problem he could not keep himself interested in anything at all. The drug help him and he is a happy active kid. I have seen many kids on those same drugs that seem catatonic. They seem like empty shells and have no interest in any thing. I have listen to doctors that say they only prescribe the drug because they know the parent will only go to a different doctor and get their child these drugs. I am not sure if it is bad parenting mean that the parent do not wish to deal with their kids or if it is the doctors not wanting to take the time to see why a kid is acting the way he or she is.
Now with what you say your brother is going though when he is on the drug I would assume that he does not have ADD or ADHD but I am not a doctor. I would recommend that he be look at by a different doctor and be up front with the doctor and tell him/her that you do not think he has ADD or ADHD. I am sure that they may agree with you and find something that will help him focus better without turning him into a zombie.
"Something given has no value"~Robert Heinlein
"Having been poor is no shame, but being ashamed of it, is." Benjamin Franklin, Poor Richards Almanack, 1749
It was a nice long one too.
I don't really have enough evidence to say that I don't think ADHD or ADD is real, but I can say that in my own experience either my brother is getting the wrong kind of medication or he actually doesn't need it.
I would assume that this medication is effective in many cases though, since doctors continue to prescribe it.
If he was my brother I would take him and find out if he does have it. I also know that there is no test to check to see if a person had ADD or ADHD. It is all done by doctor's observation. The way they hand out the pills make it seem like a magic cure for everything.
I am worried for this younger generation. I had much trouble focusing and I did bad in school it was not because I was ADD or ADHD (though I am sure if ADD or ADHD was know about then I would have been told I have it) it was the fact that I was did not want to do my homework or study because I know I would ace my tests I also did ace the tests, but without the homework I would lose 25% of my grade so the best I could get for the class would be a 75%.
If your family get him off the pills you all my have to take lots of time to ensure that he is doing his homework and not playing the Xbox 14 hours a day. I would recommend a rule that say you can not play the video games until you have finished you school work. I hope everything goes well please keep us informed.
"Something given has no value"~Robert Heinlein
"Having been poor is no shame, but being ashamed of it, is." Benjamin Franklin, Poor Richards Almanack, 1749
I agree, but I honestly don't know how to tell if he has it or not. I may be a lot more skeptical than many people, and he could very well have it.
But then again, he might not.
I also can't tell my parents what to do, and they probably know better than I do.
I do think that over-medicating kids is a BIG problem today, however.
I think the big problem with over medicating kids come for a parents that want quick fixes. They want their child to be normal within there realm of what is normal. Now these parent have made it hard for doctors to do what is right. I am not saying that your parent are like that but the few bad parent have made it hard for the good one and some times hurts the good one who think they are doing what is right for their child.
"Something given has no value"~Robert Heinlein
"Having been poor is no shame, but being ashamed of it, is." Benjamin Franklin, Poor Richards Almanack, 1749
I STRONGLY believe that my younger brother (almost 12) is ADHD. We don't have him on medications and he's often an out-of-control, aggressive child. We homeschool and my parents have daily battles to get him to do his school and chores. My parents are trying to find the right combination of supplements and other natural ways of helping him control himself. They're still working on it, but as hard as it is to live with him, I think it's probably for the long-term best.
RESPECT LIFE
SMILE EVERY DAY
"It is poverty to decide that a child must die so that you may live as you wish."
~Mother Teresa
All I can say is that I would hate to be a doctor, because that seems like a difficult call to make.
But I definitely applaud your parents for attempting to avoid medicating him--I think that's the best way to go if at all possible.