Why do you believe that?

respectlife's picture
Tagged:  •  

People go through life with three spiritual options: (1) They remain the same faith they were as children really questioning what they believe; (2) They realize they don't know why they believe what they believe and then go on this "I hate religion" spree; or (3) They analyze why they believe what they believe with a desire to know the truth. Then they either remain with the faith they were brought up in or they join another religion because they believe that religion has the Truth.

Sadly, few people know why they believe what they believe. Last week at youth group, our youth leader asked us to point out some various questions people have asked us or that we ourselves had wondered about the Catholic faith. Then she asked us for answers to those questions. For some questions, quite a few people raised their hands; at others, no one did. It made me realize even more how important it is that I understand why we honor (not worship) Mary, intercede to the saints, pray the rosary, and a variety of other Catholic traditions.

Regardless of what faith you are, it is always important to understand why you believe what you believe, not only so that you may be a witness of your faith to others, but so that you can know that you know why you believe what you believe. Every human heart longs for the truth. We do not want lies and false promises. Thus, it is important to seek the truth.

WHY do you believe in God? Why DON'T you believe in God? Why do you obey what the Bible says? What makes you so sure that the Bible's a fairy tale? Why do you have the various customs in your faith? Why are you opposed to organized religion? What does your denomination teach and where is the logic and history in what it teaches? What makes your faith better than John Doe's faith? If someone came up to you on the street and randomly asked you about a particular belief of your religion, would you be prepared to answer them? Why do you pray x times a day? Why do you rest on Saturdays/Sundays? What is the history behind the various holidays in your faith?

Ask these questions (and more!) with a desire for the truth. Question your friends on why they believe what they believe. This is a really important issue facing all people, no matter what your belief is. Know WHY you believe what you believe.

I was wondering when I would come across a blog like this. The very statement you said about questioning what you believe in has been my issue with religion my entire life. From my experience, most religions teach you to have "blind faith", to not question but just do. My reasoning always has been because they don't even know what they are trying to teach everyone else. In my opinion, religion is all based on nothing but someone's interpretations. That's would prove why we have so many different religions and all of them claiming to be the "right" religion. If all your going to do is just float around in this life and not question things you want an answer to, then "God" would have been better off making you a snail, incapable of free choice and communication.

respectlife's picture

LOL Glad to relieve the search.

Well, it's good being told everything when you're young. However, I think even children should be taught why they believe what they believe. I love how the Catholic Church has so much to it to learn, and when I really study WHY, the answers make perfect sense. : ) I've been raised in the Catholic faith, so maybe I don't count, but I have heard of converts who have converted to the Catholic Church after going on witch hunts to disprove the Church. LOL

Well, I don't know if I agree that all religions are interpretation. Of course, they are to an extent. But humans have a desire for the truth. I don't think we'd have this desire if we weren't meant for the truth. Therefore, at least one religion must have the fullness of truth.

LOL I totally agree to the last sentence!

RESPECT LIFE
http://progressiveu.org/blog/respectlife
"It is poverty to decide that a child must die so that you may live as you wish."
~Mother Teresa

mary.jane's picture

I'd never been to a Catholic Mass before I attended a dear friend's father's funeral service. I felt like an intruder at a secret club. Everyone else seemed to know when to stand, sit, or pray, as though they had gone through the contrived ritual hundreds of times before (many probably had).

I am a Buddhist, and therefore declined to receive communion, as did the three other members of my party. However, it was very awkward when the time came, as everyone else in our pew rose to exit to the center aisle and take part in the ceremony. The pew seemed designed to make those of us who were there merely to support a friend during his loss feel awkward when it came time to receive communion. Should we stand and merely let the others pass? Do we leave the pew and merely bypass the priest as he passed out wafers and then file back into the pew with the others? Of course, I'd like to believe it wasn't intentionally designed that way, but nevertheless we were put in an awkward position because we didn't know how to behave.

As for believing in the existence of God, I've never felt that an omnipotent, omnipresent being would care about the minutiae of human existence, even if he or she did supposedly create us in his or her image. Personally, I feel it's egocentric to assume a being of such power would take any more interest in humanity than a child would in an ant farm. Anything more than a cursory interest seems unlikely to me.

Far be it from me to say that my religion is "better" than anyone else's; we all have beliefs that help to define and shape our worldview. My problem with organized religion comes with the idea that one religion purports to be intrinsically "better" than another. I find Buddhism to be very pragmatic, and it jives with how I conceive of both my world and the spiritual world. Buddhism doesn't include a deity, only reverence for a wise spiritual teacher who sought to eliminate attachment and craving, and therefore suffering.

Buddhism encourages its followers to study and meditate and cultivate an understanding of themselves and others in order to free themselves from unhappiness and suffering. I have found that other religions have a tendency towards the dogmatic and discourage critical questioning of established religious tradition. The only truths in Buddhism are the four noble truths: life itself means suffering; the origin of suffering is attachment (i.e. - we suffer because we lose things to which we are attached be they people or property or what have you); the cessation of suffering is attainable; the path to cessation is the middle way between hedonism and asceticism - the gradual path to self improvement lies in living a life of moderation. Once we have learned to be free form all worries, troubles, complexities, fabrications, and attachments, we have attained Nirvana and a freedom from human suffering.

However, I am a deist in that I believe that somehow humanity (and seemingly humanity alone) was imbued with the ability to reason; it is because of this ability to reason that we suffer.

respectlife's picture

Well, Catholics are told to attend Mass every Sunday. Some don't, but to those who do, by the time you're a teenager, you could go through the motions in your sleep. That's not necessarily a good thing, though, because then we don't think about how beautiful each part of the Mass is.

Yeah, it is awkward. We believe that you're only supposed to receive Communion if you're free from mortal sin. So if a person's committed a mortal sin and not yet gone to Confession, they cannot receive Communion. We also have to fast one hour before receiving Communion, so sometimes people don't receive because of that. If you're ever in that situation again, you could go up with your arms folded across your chest and receive a blessing, if you want. Before Vatican II, people used to randomly go up instead of in the lines. I'd like that method better, actually, because then it wouldn't be so awkward to sit down and not receive Communion.

Yes, that's hard to believe. I wonder myself sometimes how in the world God can care for us so much. But His love for us is obvious through the many things He created for us for our pleasure. Right now, for example, it's fall. He gives us the beauty of the trees changing color before He allows winter to come (I'm not a big winter person : P). He promised the first parents that He would send His only begotten Son to redeem the world. That is something I have marveled over. Here are these creations that God created. He told them not to do something and they DISOBEYED Him. THEN He promises to send HIS Son to redeem THEM. I guess it goes to show that omnipotent beings are a lot nicer than us humans. o.O

That's really interesting about the Buddhist beliefs; thanks for outlining that. : ) It's interesting to see that you believe suffering is a bad thing. Catholics believe that it serves purpose. (1) It helps us to appreciate the good times (just like winter makes me appreciate summer all the more); (2) Through suffering, we have a union with Christ's sufferings on the cross; (3) We can have intercessory suffering where we suffer for intentions, such as a friend in need of prayers, the souls in Purgatory, or the unborn. This helps us to look beyond ourselves; (4) Suffering brings us closer to God. Therefore, whereas we don't always enjoy suffering, we believe it to be of good merit and not a punishment.

It's interesting you mention that. During my one week at my college's summer program, we had a variety of classes. One of the classes was philosophy and we spent the WHOLE week discussing "Can a dog be happy?" We finally reasoned no, because dogs do not have reason. : )

RESPECT LIFE
http://progressiveu.org/blog/respectlife
"It is poverty to decide that a child must die so that you may live as you wish."
~Mother Teresa

Jsaj's picture
Volunteer for the Progressive U Alumni Association

""Can a dog be happy?" ...no"
You should meet my dogs.

"Don't blame me. I voted for Kodos."
Homer Simpson

respectlife's picture

LOL Well, our ultimate conclusion after a mere week's discussion was that dogs have instincts and react on instincts but cannot be truly happy. Also, happiness depends upon your definition of happiness...and then it really gets complicated LOL

RESPECT LIFE
http://progressiveu.org/blog/respectlife
"It is poverty to decide that a child must die so that you may live as you wish."
~Mother Teresa

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.