Israel

rtotton's picture
Tagged:

“No one can afford to assume that someone else will solve their problems. Every individual has a responsibility to help guide our global family in the right direction. Good wishes are not sufficient; we must become actively engaged.” ~The Dahlia Lama
In today’s world, individuals cannot afford to be apathetic. Apathy puts the lives of others at risk. Yet, Americans are typically thought of as being a red, white, and blue wave of apathy. I have chosen to actively engage myself in global issues and overcome America’s apathetic label. I thrust myself face first into the global scene in the summer of 2007 through a pilgrimage to Israel. It was a ten day trip that made apathy impossible.
Personally, I am strongly set in my religious convictions, and when I was surrounded by such diverse religious cultures, all of which are also very set in their religious convictions, I realized that world religions have a major impact on how the globe functions. People are often so fervent in their opinions that they refuse to accept the idea that issues are always shades of gray and never as black and white as they may seem. Religious disputes have led to wars and mass murders. In fact, religions are one of the main issues currently causing friction in Israel. For example, Ahkmed, our bus driver who was kind enough to take my pilgrim group all over Israel, told our group about the Hebron Mosque massacre of 1994. A Jewish man walked in to the Hebron Mosque and killed twenty-nine Muslims at prayer because he believed that all Muslims were evil. The capital of Israel, Jerusalem, finds itself divided into four quarters, Jewish, Muslim, Christian, and Armenian. People across the world cannot grasp that openness to the opinions of others does not mean admission of their ideals. This type of closed-minded prejudice is one of the barriers that keeps the world from being a more diversity-respectful place.
Americans are incredibly apathetic because the American system of politics has not been seriously threatened since the time of the Civil War. Even though many Americans complain about how terrible the country is, most are confident that democracy will not fail them. A visit to Israel showed me that every country that claims democracy is not necessarily as impartial in their governing as America. Ahkmed drove my fellow pilgrims and me to the Dead Sea one day. This part of the Dead Sea is within the land that some know as Palestine, or the eastern-most part of the West Bank. Ahkmed is a Palestinian Muslim who lives in Jerusalem. Even though he is a citizen of Israel, and does not even live in the West Bank area, he was not allowed to go to the Dead Sea with us. In fact, no Palestinians are allowed to be in the Dead Sea. As we entered, everyone was asked to show passports to prove that we were not Palestinians (apparently the white skin wasn’t enough). Americans moved past the last of this forty-some years ago with desegregation in the south, and the majority are mortified at the idea of separation by race; yet, in some countries it is still a common occurrence. Later on the same day, back at our hotel, a group of people tried to call a cab to go out. The cab driver said that it would be impossible to go out right now because the Israeli government had put road blocks on several major roads for the night. The next morning I asked Ahkmed why the roads had been closed. Ahkmed replied, “The government wants to remind everyone who the boss is. They do that every now and then just to tell people not to get any bright ideas.” One would hope that Americans would be furious if the government closed down roads for no reason. Yet, with the lack of response from recent wiretapping in America, it appears American indifference has reached a new high. The longer Americans continue this lackadaisical attitude towards politics and the world in general, the more susceptible the American system becomes to corruption.
NBC and ABC are happy to show viewers an interview with Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the president of Iran, to show the fighting in Iraq, or the conflict between Palestinians and Israelis. However, major news stations seldom show are the pains and struggles of the everyday person in those countries. I have yet to see a story about a man like Ahkmed, who is endlessly oppressed by his “democratic” government, and yet continues to be honest and non-violent. Ahkmed was enrolled in law school, but because of the way that Israel is right now, ended up becoming a bus driver. He has three beautiful, kind-hearted children who he raises to be non-judgmental and concerned for the welfare of others. Yet, rarely has a story appeared on the news about a man like him. He is one of millions who are misrepresented and ignored. Newscasters show the stories that will get ratings. The more apathetic Americans become to global events, the more shocking the news stories must become to catch the viewer’s attention. This results in the meager coverage of political unrest such as Darfur, Uganda, Myanmar, and Palestine. When these places do appear on the news it is nearly always about fighting or protesting. Knowing about current fighting or protesting is of vital importance; however, it is even more critical, and far more useful, to look not only at the fighting, but what has actually caused this strife. It is terribly important that humanity look at the everyday stories of those who are struggling to feed their families. Many Americans in today’s world are too self absorbed to truly look at the big picture and take action to promote justice.
On June 16th, 1963, John Fitzgerald Kennedy told East Berliners: “Ich bin ein Berliner”, or “I am a citizen of Berlin”. On that day President Kennedy told the world that when the citizens of one nation suffer, the world suffers. That is just as true today, although fewer Americans believe it. Israel revolutionized my world views. I took a major cultural step away from the American mind set of caring more about Britney’s shaved head or Lindsay’s rehab issues than the crisis in Darfur. I opened myself up to new experiences, cultures, ways of thinking, and new and fascinating people. America must take a stand and become concerned with the emotions and sufferings of the rest of the world before it is too late. Many foreign countries are already at odds with American policies and situations are not improving. Apathy is the American plague; it is time to step up and be the cure.

0
No votes yet
Kiota's picture

"For example, Ahkmed, our bus driver who was kind enough to take my pilgrim group all over Israel, told our group about the Hebron Mosque massacre of 1994. A Jewish man walked in to the Hebron Mosque and killed twenty-nine Muslims at prayer because he believed that all Muslims were evil."

How interesting that he told you about one of the VERY few psycho killer Jews and not of the many, many Islamic terrorists who target ANYONE regardless of their victim's religion.

"The capital of Israel, Jerusalem, finds itself divided into four quarters, Jewish, Muslim, Christian, and Armenian."

Um, no, it is not.

The "old city", which is the walled part of Jerusalem, which is a SMALL part of Jerusalem, has four quarters with plenty of intermingling. There's no rule against Jews being in the Christian quarter, Muslims being in the Jewish quarter, etc.

"Ahkmed is a Palestinian Muslim who lives in Jerusalem. Even though he is a citizen of Israel, and does not even live in the West Bank area, he was not allowed to go to the Dead Sea with us. In fact, no Palestinians are allowed to be in the Dead Sea. As we entered, everyone was asked to show passports to prove that we were not Palestinians (apparently the white skin wasn’t enough)."

No Palestinians are allowed to be in the Dead Sea? That's funny, I've seen loads of Muslim-Arab men and women there. What IS a Palestinian? If he's a citizen of Israel, he's Israeli, not Palestinian. You had to show your passports to show you were there legally. Not to prove you were not "Palestinian" (whatever that means).

And white skin? Um. Did you look around you in Israel? There's white people, brown people, black people. They're all Israeli, mostly Jewish. Middle-eastern Jews and Muslims look PRECISELY the same, so what's this hype about skin color?

"The next morning I asked Ahkmed why the roads had been closed. Ahkmed replied, “The government wants to remind everyone who the boss is. They do that every now and then just to tell people not to get any bright ideas.”"

Right, so the government gets its citizens all pissed off and spends a huge amount of money and resources to "remind everyone who the boss is"? Doubtful. Why are you so quick to believe there wasn't a reason you don't know of? Daily there are scores of warnings of terrorist attacks. Such road blocks have saved many lives.

"I have yet to see a story about a man like Ahkmed, who is endlessly oppressed by his “democratic” government, and yet continues to be honest and non-violent. "

Which government? The Palestinian Authority (which has alloted billions of dollars in aid donations to terrorist groups instead of its own people), or the government of Israel (which is also the only government in the middle-east that is democratic, and also has Arab-Muslims in it)?

Your mistaken beliefs about Israel aside, this is a great post.

Jsaj's picture
Volunteer for the Progressive U Alumni Association

I do not condone many of the actions that the Israeli government has taken. However, your post has a number of problems. First of all, it is immensely one-sided. Yes, Israel hasn't always behaved in the most rational or fair way, but the Palestinian faction has committed its share of atrocities at least as bad as Israel's.
And, of course, you have no sources, which is a big problem, when you say things like 'Palestinians can't go to the dead sea'.

"Don't blame me. I voted for Kodos."
Homer Simpson

rtotton's picture

I appologize for my seemingly one sided veiws. Partially this so one sided because of the school prompt i was given. Part of this was my own expirences. For example the palistineans not being allowed in the dead sea was something i personally expirenced. Maybe that was for another reason... i'm just telling what i witnessed. I understand that the issues in Israel are far from one sided and there is no simple answer. I should have put a note along with this mentioning all of that before hand.

Jsaj's picture
Volunteer for the Progressive U Alumni Association

Again, can you provide some sort of source about the dead sea thing. Not what a bus driver said, with all due respect to said bus driver. For instance, the Israeli board of Tourism, or the official dead sea tourism site or whatever.

"Don't blame me. I voted for Kodos."
Homer Simpson

Kiota's picture

Are you going to respond to my post, as well? And the Palestinians not being allowed at the Dead Sea part is bs.

rtotton's picture

http://domino.un.org/unispal.nsf/bc8b0c56b7bf621185256cbf005ac05f/23bdff1f2f8537998525711600580642!OpenDocument
if you copy paste that it should show you a nice article on it. and i heard the gaurd say this... not just my bus driver.

Jsaj's picture
Volunteer for the Progressive U Alumni Association

According to your article, the guard was lying. It said that Palestinians who don't live in the region couldn't get in. Wrong, if true.
Let's see. The government hasn't decided on the issue and the entire populace are in the dark. Hmmm.....

"Don't blame me. I voted for Kodos."
Homer Simpson

rtotton's picture

Well Ahkmed lived in Jerusalm which is obviously within israel, but not within the west bank region. so that makes sence.
and once again im not saying that the issues are all the israeli governments fault. i think there is alot of fault on both sides. like i said i was just stating one side of it and suggesting that my expirence there was that the government came across as rather biased.

Jsaj's picture
Volunteer for the Progressive U Alumni Association

Please use the reply link at the bottom of text box's.

"Don't blame me. I voted for Kodos."
Homer Simpson

Don't be discouraged by the comments you have received. These views and opinions represent an almost unanimous opinion in the United States, among both conservatives and liberals. What you saw and experienced, despite what these people are arguing, is a lot closer to the truth then anything they are saying. I don't know how much you know about the history of Palestine or the creation of Israel, but it is one that is generally told only from the perspectives of Zionism. Usually i would take out the time to argue certain points against these other commenters, but I plan on writing more extensive and in-depth blog entries on this topic. I feel that a few statistics in a comment just won't do the issue justice.

It is very rare for me to find someone like you who is even willing to listen to the other perspective. If you want, I have a number of websites and book recommendations if you are interested in further exploring the topic.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing."

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.