Where Have We Gone Wrong, America?*

tangle's picture

I cannot escape racism. It paints my world in stark, thick, contrasting strokes of black and white. So it goes that I devote much thought to the matter of that social construct so casually referred to as race. (In a very similar manner, I might add, that I cannot help but to constantly consider gender as it shapes my world. But that’s another blog entirely.) And so I shall write yet another blog about race...

As a preliminary matter we must clarify a few important concepts:

Race is a social construct that causes of groups people who posses distinguishable physical traits to be held in low esteem by the dominant group. It is an ascribed status.

An ascribed status is a social status that an individual occupies irrespective of his or her actions, whereas an achieved status is a social status that is attained through one’s choices or accomplishments.

Hypodescent is when societies ascribe minority status to children born of unions between members of dominant and minority groups.

Minority groups are so defined because of their lack of access to power and privilege, not because of their numbers.

And with those clarifications hopefully clear, we shall proceed.

When considering the existence of racism I’m first struck by the observation that skin color seems a perfectly well suited mechanism by which to ‘otherize’ those that are not of your group. While that seems perfectly reasonable and benign, somehow it happened that the construction of modern racism has had disastrous consequences throughout my nation’s history.

From it’s inception America has been an experiment in the amalgamation of multiple cultures and ethnic groups. First, the brown indigenous Americans were colonized by the white Europeans. Then the brown indigenous Africans were colonized by the Europeans, and many of them were shipped over to the Americas as unpaid labor. The colonization of the indigenous Americans turned to genocide within 250 years (Indian Removal Act of 1830), all the while with the Africans remaining enslaved until 1863, with discrimination continuing into the present day.

Here in the year 2008 this sordid history has some profound and interesting results. Despite the philosophical, ideological and technological advancements America has made, she continues to be afflicted with the social ill of racism.

Somehow, skin color continues be a defining criteria of one’s life experience. I, for one, am horrified by this reality, and I’m at a loss as to what to do to fix it. All I can do, and what I am doing, is to educate myself and try to educate others, because ignorance breeds intolerance.

One of the most important things folks need to learn is that race is socially constructed, as mentioned above. In other words, there is no such thing as biological race. There’s only one race of hominid that we consider human, and there’s only a single such race in existence at this time. Skin color variation in hominins does not correspond to breed variation in canines. To speak of racial difference is a misnomer to describe human diversity in socially charged terms.

That being the case, that we’re all just humans with epidermis of varying shades, it's unfathomable to me that we continue to treat race as a concrete thing, as if skin tone should really make a difference in our day to day lives.

What do you think?

_____________________________________________________________

*To give credit where credit is due, I'm hereby crediting Tori Amos with this turn of phrase.
_____________________________________________________________

In the interest of full disclosure I’m compelled to offer a few details about myself so as to lay bare my biases and, hopefully - although not likely, circumvent anyone from making any baseless assumptions about my motivations.

I’m a white female. I was born in Alabama, a state that epitomizes the Deep South, and I’ve lived in Mississippi, another a state that epitomizes the Deep South, for more than ten years. It happened that I also spent over a decade of my formative years in South Florida. While I wouldn’t go so far as to say that my family has been crippled by poverty I would still call us poor. I didn’t graduate from high school because I stayed home for too long taking care of my baby half-brother when that was our circumstance dictated. Not one to let Fate commandeer my life course so easily I obtained a GED and scored high enough on the ACT to score an academic scholarship at a community college. I ended up working as a legal secretary midway through my community college tenure and I’ve been doing that ever since to make ends meet. In the meanwhile I got married (to a white male) and enrolled as a transfer student at an HBCU, again on an academic scholarship, and in May I’ll obtain a Bachelor of Arts degree in History.

Although I’m getting my degree in history I’m a sociologist in truth. Of the opinion that humanities studies ought not be so rigidly compartmentalized, I’m seeking a longer, more ethnological perspective of the ways societies have functioned (or ceased to function) throughout the historical record.

zena princess's picture

I'm female, older and have a depressive disorder. You think you got problems now??? Just wait. I think you will find this blog was a bit premature....discrimination is discrimination wheter you have 'skin' or color at ALL! Rascism my foot.. foreigners have been treated better than me and my family by our OWN countrymen. And yes, I"M WHITE!

Me too***
There's a group of ladies from the same race at the hospital where a friend of mine works. Anytime someone else is hired who isn't their race, they treat him like shit and then accuse the my friend of racism for not employing one of those(people of their race) they recommended . That person eventually is forced out and they invite someone of their race to fill in the position. It's sickening.

tangle's picture

You think you got problems now???
I don't think I have problems; I think this country is rife with them.

I think you will find this blog was a bit premature....
I happen to think that half the fun of blogging is that it allows one to see how one's opinions and philosophies evolve over time (and, in an atmosphere such as this, in relation to the responses generated by the sharing of one's ideas), almost forcing one to further refine and articulate her position on any given issue.

discrimination is discrimination wheter you have 'skin' or color at ALL! Rascism my foot.. foreigners have been treated better than me and my family by our OWN countrymen. And yes, I"M WHITE!
While it's true enough that whites, too, can be the victims of discrimination, this fact only serves to highlight the impartial dimension of race, showing how, in certain situations the construct of race, which has historically befitted those with 'white' skin, can actually work against the dominant group.

/jkh

Volunteer for the Progressive U Alumni Association

Actually, skin color is produced by one or more genes. Sub-Saharan Africans also have a gene that prevents malaria. So yes, technically speaking, we could be considered as different "breeds" in much the same way the rest of the animal kingdom is classified. We aren't, primarily due to lack of knowledge because our differences are a little harder to pin down than say, the facial structure differences of a Greyhound and a Pug.

What you may find ironic is that it's the Europeans/Anglos/Whites/Aryans/whatever you want to label us that carry the mutated version of the gene, since it's presumed that most of humanity started out dark-skinned (since we started more or less in the Middle East).

I'd go into more, but I have to get going.

-- quis custodiet ipsos custodes?

tangle's picture

It's irrelevant that skin color is biological; racial classification remains a social construct.

It's akin to the social construction of gender. Sex is biological but gender is socially construed, much like race.

/jkh

Volunteer for the Progressive U Alumni Association

In other words, there is not such thing as biological race. There’s only one race of hominid that we consider human, and there’s only a single such race in existence at this time. Skin color variation in hominins does not correspond to breed variation in canines.

You said it, I was simply correcting your assertion. Technically speaking, it's actually the same concept. We just have fewer and less obvious physical differences between ourselves than dogs do.

Is there a biological difference between races of humans in the same fashion as the biological differences in dog breeds? Yes. Does that make it right to discriminate against one another? No.

-- quis custodiet ipsos custodes?

AdamLabo's picture
Volunteer for the Progressive U Alumni Association

From Wikipedia: (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_%28classification_of_human_beings%29)
The term race refers to the concept of dividing people into populations or groups on the basis of various sets of characteristics and beliefs about common ancestry.[1] The most widely used human racial categories are based on visible traits (especially skin color, cranial or facial features and hair texture), and self-identification.

From About.com: (http://racerelations.about.com/od/skillsbuildingresources/g/racedef.htm)
Definition: race (n) a human population considered distinct based on physical characteristics.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I don't see where you see that race can be defined by using low self esteem or dominant groups. Race has nothing to do with a dominant group holding another group in low self esteem. That concept makes no sense to me?? Your definition is flawed.

Your definition: (http://www.progressiveu.org/171138-where-have-we-gone-wrong-america)
Race is a social construct that causes of groups people who posses distinguishable physical traits to be held in low esteem by the dominant group. It is an ascribed status.

--------
Respectfully,
Adam

tangle's picture

I don't see where you see that race can be defined by using low self esteem or dominant groups.
Not self-esteem; just "esteem". (You know, the noun referring to the condition of being honored, respected, or well regarded?)

Race is a social construct, based on physical/physiological characteristics, which serves as a basis for otherization, which in turn allows for the partitioning of society into dominate and subordinate groups. Or at least it does (and has historically done so) here in the United States.

Race has nothing to do with a dominant group holding another group in low self (sic) esteem.
Are you seriously proposing that race has nothing to do with the formation and interaction of dominant and minority groups? I honestly find it hard to believe that this apparent fact could be disputed.

If you are honestly convinced that race has little to do with the power interplays between societal groups, please do enlighten me as to how you could propose that race has NOTHING to do with the prejudice and discrimination experienced by minority groups, or the elite status enjoyed by dominant groups.

/jkh

Volunteer for the Progressive U Alumni Association

Or at least it does (and has historically done so) here in the United States.

A lot of European countries are historically pretty racially homogeneous compared to the United States, therefore there's a lot more racial interaction and, consequently (because there's always people who are prejudice) racial tension.

Are you seriously proposing that race has nothing to do with the formation and interaction of dominant and minority groups?

Race contributes to it, but doesn't really cause it. It's oftentimes economical class that is the prime factor. Unfortunately, a lot of the black population is in a lower economical class, and therefore gives the appearance that it's more of a racial issue than it really is.

That's not to say that race isn't a factor, however it's far from the only factor. The Irish, for example, were discriminated against when they first came to America and they're as white as British whose descendants controlled this country.

-- quis custodiet ipsos custodes?

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.