Extreme Juxtaposition: My hypocracy

Carrot's picture

So my sister and I had a very serious conversation the other day about how hypocritical it is for me to critisize the way 99.9% of the population lives, while I live in this little bubble of radicial idealism which makes it easy to live the way I believe in.

She has a point: especially when I look closely at some of my behaviors which I know are seriously environmentally destructive, yet I continue to do them. Flying, for example. I laughed through Gore's movie "An Incovienant Truth," because every-other scene was of him on his laptop flying to his next speaking engagement, and he himself admited that flying was one of the worse carbon producting activities humans engage in. I thought the movie was ironic; Gore is telling large groups of people all over the country to fly less to reduce carbon impact, and is flying there to tell them that. Yet I do the same. Every time I come to New York, I consider other traveling options that are less destrictive: hitchhiking, ride-sharing, train-jumping, but in the end, because of the convienance of flying, and because my family always insists on buying me a ticket, I end up flying. I love flying; it freaks me out, I always think we are going to crash and die, so it gets my adrenaline flowing and I absolutely love that terrifying feeling. I know I could get that feeling hitchhiking (I used to hitch all the time,) but it takes nearly a week to get across the country, whereas flying is an overnight trip. Also, my grandmother made me promise I'd never hitchhike again after a cross country trip that had my family freaked out, but I might have to break that promise for the sake of environmentally-friendly travel.

So I'm a hypocrite. I take car-rides when they are offered to me, I eat food in excessive packaging that get thrown away after one use, I still use napkins and paper towels and excessive amounts of toliet paper. When I'm in New York, I drink water from a jug, because I don't trust the well-water that is my only other option. I used to drink well-water all the time growing up, but the water has a funny stickyness to it now that I don't remember it having before, and I'm convinced the larger farms that have grown up around my families' land has something to do with this. I'm scared of pestisides, although I eat fruit that isn't organic (sometimes, usually I get organic,) and I don't rinse it before eating.

My habits definately get worse when I'm not in my bubble...it's easier not to give a shit when nobody around you does....and when you are out in the middle of nowhere, it is almost impossible to not travel by car...unless you want to spend a day biking to the next town over. It is also harder to find organic food, and ironically enough, with all the large farms right next door, it is extremely hard to find quality locally-produced foods, if you don't grow them yourself. Farmer's markets and health-food stores aren't the norm out here...people eat really crappy foods, which seems so ironic, considering that this is farm country. But this is because the food being produced on the farm next door is being shipped to a factory someplace far away to be made into something else...potatoes from "The Muck" out here get shipped to a Lays factory to be made into potatoe chips I've heard...so that's a great example. If I had a car, I could probably eat all locally produced foods...but I would probably have to drive to six or seven different towns just to gather all the foods I needed. I would produce more carbon-shit just getting all the "local' foods then I would be saving. Life out here just seems really ironic in so many ways. So people can't drink water from their own wells out here anymore because of the large farms all around them, but they don't benefit from the food being produced by these large farms either...they have crappy food and crappy water...a lose/lose siduation if you ask me.

Other ironies abound...this is an area of wonderful wilderness: 1) The Finger Lakes 2) The Adirondack Mountains 3) Lake Erie (one of the Great Lakes,) 4) Niagria Falls 5) Walkins Glen 6) The Ithaca Gorges 7) countless swamps/protected areas for birds. In order to enjoy these wild areas though, people buy or rent motorboats, drive all over the place, rent cottages on the lakes (which, by the way, have septic systems that go into the lakes still..!), etc. I myself do these things. I am part of the tourist industry that is slowly destroying the very beauty we come to New York to see. I was poundering all of this yesterday while standing up on this bird tower thing built out in a "protected' swamp area across the road from my friend Holly's art studio. To get out to the tower, you hike through this marshy area on a trail...a trail that is littered by campfire sites, candy wrappers, fishing equiptment that has been dropped (hooks, fishline, plastic lures,) energy drink bottles, beer cans and all the other disgusting reminders that even "protected" areas are disrespected by humans who are supposedly "enjoying nature." I was walking with a dog I was watching for Holly...the dog kept stopping to poop and pee...also the dog was chasing nesting birds; doing natural dog things. I kept thinking "these protected birds can't escape anywhere from human activity...even here in the "protected swamp" they have to endure dogs, fires, fishing, drunks, pesticides, hikers, all sorts of trash..."

What can we do? How do we change the ironies in our own lives? How do I enjoy nature without enabling the destruction of it? On that note, I'm gonna go water the trees my sister and I planted...

Love ya,
Carrot

0

I think to a certain extent we are all hipocrits, but when you have such a passionate belief (of anything really) it makes it twice as hard to avoid hypocrisy. All environmentalists have this issue because it's almost impossible not to break your own rules and live in a society that is based off of everything you despise. I'm no environmentalist, but I understand where you're coming from. I'm not sure what this means for us as individuals... maybe that we should be more tolerant of others... or maybe that we should be less tolerant of ourselves.

kablock's picture
Member of the Progressive U Alumni Association

I'm a firm believer in the "do what you can" mentality. Just the fact that you're conscious of the impacts in your life, I believe, are going to naturally make those impacts less. Also, I'm sure you do tons of other things to live sustainably whenever you can, and that certainly helps.

So do what you can when you can do it. Having to drive to the store because you live far away is a neccessity that can only really be solved by moving or trying to make/grow everything you could ever possibly need. The ironies in our lives are put there because we can't live in tents or teepees without running water. Simply having a house means having a negative environmental impact. We do what we can to lessen our impact and try to change the system, and I think that that's enough.
-------------------------
Honest disagreement is often a good sign of progress. --Mahatma Gandhi

My Blog: http://www.progressiveu.org/blog/kablock
My PhotoBlog: http://takingpictures.wordpress.com

Carrot's picture
Member of the Progressive U Alumni Association

without running water? I've been thinking about this lately...the huge impact of say, just turning on a faucet to get a drink of water. First, you have the impact of the electricity used to turn on the pump to get the water to you; you have the impact of all the pipes and such that where made to connect the water source to your faucet. If you aren't drinking well-water (and most of us aren't,) you have huge water treatment facilities, chemicals to make our water "clean", etc.

It is sad/scary that many of us, even here in the US no longer have clean water...in Des Moines Iowa, for example, mothers are now advised not to use tap water in certain times in the spring to make formula or food for their babies, as the high levels of pesicides in the water cause the babies to go into shock and turn blue and stop breathing...I'd say that is a pretty serious thing...

It used to be that only "those places overseas" had problems like that... but now that we do to, we are starting to become concerned with the environment. At this point, it feels a little late in the game to worry..but we should still do everything we can to help.

Love ya,
Carrot

kablock's picture
Member of the Progressive U Alumni Association

Well, I was speaking more in terms of available widespread changes. I can't see Congress legislating to make everyone live in teepees again. It just goes against that nebulous idea of "progress" that we Americans are so fond of.

Nevertheless, there is no question that we are having a huge impact on our environment with every little, everyday thing that we do. I don't think we can ever get rid of that impact altogether.
-------------------------
Honest disagreement is often a good sign of progress. --Mahatma Gandhi

My Blog: http://www.progressiveu.org/blog/kablock
My PhotoBlog: http://takingpictures.wordpress.com

Carrot's picture
Member of the Progressive U Alumni Association

pass legislation like that! I'm in favor of less/smaller government and more individual control..but certainly some people would choose to live that way if zoning laws where a little less strict. I think in fact people would choose to live all sorts of ways if they actually had a choice about how they lived...rather then being told they have to live in structures with certain requirements like running water and flushing toliets.

I think it is unavoidable, as a living, breathing human not to have an impact on the environment...certainly even the !Kung people in the Kalahari Desert have something of an impact...but we can all work to give back as much to our landbase as we take...that is what I want to aim for. I'm very far from this lifestyle so far, but I want to move towards it...

Love ya,
Carrot

kablock's picture
Member of the Progressive U Alumni Association

There probably would be more people who would choose to live in tents rather than houses if they were allowed. And I love how you worded that: "give back as much to our landbase as we take." It's really what we need to do, in whatever way we can.
-------------------------
Honest disagreement is often a good sign of progress. --Mahatma Gandhi

My Blog: http://www.progressiveu.org/blog/kablock
My PhotoBlog: http://takingpictures.wordpress.com

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.