I think he doesn’t know how close he has brought the reality of all things related to the military into my life; it is ironic...I think it's the selfish soul inside of me.
My uncle (my dad’s older brother) was in the Pakistani Army. One of my great Uncles was a POW, in a war between India and Pakistan- people thought he was dead but he was released in an exchange of prisoners after the war- (his son was also in the Pakistani Army). Basically…the army is an extremely significant part of the society in Pakistan too; it has been, in times of peace and of course in war.
In fact, Fareed Zakaria, a writer for Newsweek explained that, some countries have armies but Pakistan is an army that has a country, unfortunately. Furthermore, living in the US--I have friends who have joined the army…I have classmates who have come from over there (Iraq). The army, military things, soldiers, friends and all loved ones part of this institution, in essence, have been my life since I was born.
He, who says he wants to join, is like a brother. A Pakistani citizen, my dad’s dead friend’s youngest son who I think is being too hasty in this decision.
-----------He is intelligent, mature, too young to be this stressed. He has the weight, he thinks, of his world on his shoulders. I asked him why…I knew the reasons, the answer I was going to get was one I expected and yet…I was hoping for a weak argument, something I could break down easily.
He said those reasons that I know drive many people, especially in Pakistan, to join. He thinks that the sooner he becomes a part of something where he can get money and especially benefits (Army in Pak is also treated well, I know it), he can help his mom. His mom, who has been struggling after the death of her husband five years ago, deserves so much and her youngest son wants to give up other possibilities and join the Army. He has two older brothers already trying hard to make it all good for their mom but he is taking responsibility of things he should not be worried about.
I respect and treasure the military and army. I value it dearly. I cherish those who put their lives in the line of bullets and bombs. My uncle did it, my dad wanted to join, but was unable to because of his parents (they only wanted one in the army). I have a friend from high school who joined, I have classmates who are thinking of and who have already decided and have been there and back. I know all this, the numbers, the things they do. All that is them is something I could only humbly thank and be grateful for BUT I don’t know why but my heart says He should not.
Who am I to tell him? I haven’t even seen him face to face in five years but he knows how much I love him and I know how much he loves me and my family. I can’t tell him it’s foolish, immature…he’s too smart to not have weighed all his options. I want him to attend a university. I can’t imagine losing him in any sort of combat.
It’s me who is being childish, immature and selfish…but this is a guy whose growth I have witnessed--some through my own eyes, some through his pictures and his conversations with me on MSN. He is not the short and boyish youth anymore. He is not the boy who used to make jokes, was a partner in childish pranks with his older brother (my age), and was the mastermind behind the ghost stories.
What should I say? I wish for the funny guy to have remained but life has changed him. His father’s unexpected death had the greatest impact on all of them. I can’t explain why tears fall. I think of the past and remember those old and gold times. They are not my blood yet I don’t know how my life would have been without them. They are family. They were my only loved ones when everyone else from my actual family had already moved to the U.S. What’s the point of this blog? I’m just blue. I can’t accept the Army as his future, stupid and selfish of me but…I can’t help it.
Edited to add- I think I have figured it out. I don’t want to “whore out my emotions,” (I read another blog that made me question my own writing)-I want to say that I am Upset, emotional and fed up with the unfairness of it all. (Life, the world, one's circumstances--things out of my control)
I really don’t think that one should have the mind set that joining the army is the only way that they’d be able to become something or be a part of something great.
As I said before, it’s not that I don’t respect this organization and what they do… BUT it just is not something that people should have to resort to because they feel they have no other road and path to take because of their circumstances.
We, youngsters and people in general, should have more options, feel less helpless, and the opportunities should not be limited for a person who comes from a disadvantaged back ground --who has no support from anywhere that he (as other young people) considers it to be the only option and the only way to truly succeed without having setbacks and hindrances. This isn't only one person. I know of many people who go through this decision making process to come at the conclusion that the Army would be the best avenue for them to take.











http://www.progressiveu.org/090204-dont-miss-this-chance
oh...please don't be blue. We all must change whether it is through old age or through experience and you too will come out changed by all of this. All we will have left is childhood innocence to remember once we are grown.
This was a truly touching blog and he is so lucky to have a friend who understands him and supports him despite your difference in opinions.
"My uncle did it, my dad wanted to join, but was unable to because of his parents (they only wanted one in the army). "
Wow. Your culture obviously demands the highest respect from children to their parents, which I find hard to do when you want to go your own way but i respect that in cultures.
he was actually sent to a Qur'an teacher from a very young age to help him memorize and understand the Qur'an (it's a really big deal) In urdu, he is called a Hafiz, i don't know how else to translate other than he knows almost all the Qur'an by heart (the arabic) and he knows the translations for many passages. His parents were the one who asked him to do it...and he did it--- it was a big dedication of his parents and my dad's, he used to not do any other studying until he was done memorizing the Qur'an passages he was assingned...
So my dad's older brother joined the army-- My uncle passed away in an accident about 25 years ago when my dad was very young (not even married) and after that, my grandparents were just so traumatized...
Ah, depressing to talk about this, BUT it's life :)
"The good life, let's go on a living spree
Shit they say the best things in life are free" --*K A N Y E
http://www.progressiveu.org/231615-this-is-a-muslim-girls-plight
IT's not selfish to be concerned.
and have gone through all this and it's like I knew it but when someone you don't expect to say a certain things, says it, it's just not easy to accept....
I don't know,,,,he's young but old enough to know how to make a decision for his life and I can't say much except i don't think he should do this...in the end, it's up to him
"The good life, let's go on a living spree
Shit they say the best things in life are free" --*K A N Y E
http://www.progressiveu.org/231615-this-is-a-muslim-girls-plight
http://www.progressiveu.org/090204-dont-miss-this-chance
Do you think that he shouldn't do this because he might lose his life? Life is full of dangers and if you don't stand for something and accept the dangers/consequences with it then that is a life not yet lived.
people die, I am talking about everything that is part and parcel of being in the military...I don't want to accept the fact that he knows what he is getting into..I don't think he is actually doing it other than because of his current circumstances
and I explained he is in Pakistan so it's not like I see him everyday but I talk to him and I know he is doing well studying-------but...how to explain...
he's a little brother to me who I was expecting to go on to university and major in some really demanding field and be great in it...
I just did not expect him to drop this bomb (yeah) of joining the army and he is Serious about it..
"The good life, let's go on a living spree
Shit they say the best things in life are free" --*K A N Y E
http://www.progressiveu.org/231615-this-is-a-muslim-girls-plight
http://www.progressiveu.org/090204-dont-miss-this-chance
Oh, well if thats the big deal I don't see what the fuss is. He is still studying and when he gets back from the military and makes a lot of money, he should have no problem going to a university and majoring in a demanding degree. Its not like he signed up for life, you know. The fact that he can even STUDY while in the military suggests he has time to educate himself so its really not that bad.
http://www.progressiveu.org/090204-dont-miss-this-chance
well she called herself selfish because she wanted the joy of having him home with her, instead of having him at war serving his country-which is totally understandable. But she is unselfish because she didn't stop him and she respects his choice. Its not selfish for wanting something to be one way when it can't be and things have to change.
http://www.progressiveu.org/090204-dont-miss-this-chance
I am very sorry for the loss. Is the Qur'an the right way to say Koran? Or are they completely different? It just sounds similar.
it's how you would pronounce it but I've read it spelled Koran in many places, i tend to use the Q spelling...
ah, don't be sorry, it was just something that happened, I never even met my uncle--It's just what was supposed to happen...
his daughters (2) were 5 and 3 at the time and now they are 30 and 28...
"The good life, let's go on a living spree
Shit they say the best things in life are free" --*K A N Y E
http://www.progressiveu.org/231615-this-is-a-muslim-girls-plight
http://www.progressiveu.org/090204-dont-miss-this-chance
So its supposed to be pronounced KOOORAN? Not Koran? Hmm. interesting. Well, I have everything turns out okay and at least you still have contact with him. He doesn't regret joining the army does he? Because if he is happy, then that is all that matters. If he is happy with what he is doing and that it will help his mom.
I had the same feeling when some of my older friends went into the Army for benefits in college education. I didn't want to go because I kept on having this nagging feeling that I wouldn't see them again. At the same time, I didn't have the heart to stop them. We have to support their decisions no matter what. It's hard. Still, we have to try. Heck, even I want to be in the military. I know it will change my current point of views in so many ways. Sigh. I wish I was old enough. I wish I was a U.S. citizens. I don't think they allow women to be in the military in Thailand. lol Maybe I might have to fight US soldiers one day...Nah, Thai people are too friendly to have wars with anyone...unless they attack us first....
----------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.mylot.com/?ref=truelife
http://www.progressiveu.org/090204-dont-miss-this-chance
OHh, ALWAYS listen to your gut. Thats a terrible feeling. When you know that there is impending doom but you can't do anything about it because no one ever listens and then the inevitable happens and you feel totally out of control and guilty. but still... I hope everything turns out okay.
You feel your friend has potential that benefits the world in many other ways as well; it's understandable. Don't feel as if you are being unappreciative of the armed forces.
I had a friend who wishes he chose college instead of military, although he is proud of all the fighting he's ever done. He sees the civilian career options he can't have right now, and is back in school with a passion.
I am sure that others have experienced some of the same feelings and can sympathize, I am not anti-military or against the troops in any way.
I just don't support those people who declare the wars without a viable and trustworthy reason.
"Wealth, however, does have one advantage over looks: beauty fades, interest accrues." -- Dan Savage.
"Wealth never decreases because of charity." Prophet Muhammad (pbuh)
http://www.progressiveu.org/231615-this-is-a-muslim-girls-plight
http://www.progressiveu.org/090204-dont-miss-this-chance
Well if he is proud of the fighting he did why should he wish he chose college in instead? Its not like a once in a lifetime opportunity...people as old as 80 have gone to college. Whats wrong with doing both?
He has said it to me that he thinks, the Army is his only option because he doesn't have money for university.
His dad [my uncle] died in a car accident, about 5 years ago and this is his youngest son-----There are 4 of them... 3 guys, 1 girl.
The oldest is a girl and she just got married and a lot of the family's saved up money was used for that. This youngest brother knows that his mom and older brothers can't afford his education so he thinks the Army is his best option.
Think of it like this--- Is college the same when the rest of the people your age have a job and a family and also, wouldn't you rather be sitting in a classroom with them, rather than training for the Army.
I know it's a great thing to be in an army classroom but no one should have to choose it because they don't have money to go to the other college/university.
He is very well qualified (his grades are excellent) but the fact is, the scholarships are very limited in pakistan.
"Wealth, however, does have one advantage over looks: beauty fades, interest accrues." -- Dan Savage.
"Wealth never decreases because of charity." Prophet Muhammad (pbuh)
http://www.progressiveu.org/231615-this-is-a-muslim-girls-plight
http://www.progressiveu.org/090204-dont-miss-this-chance
OOOps. Sorry guys I accidently quadruple posted. Anyways, I just can't understand those people who don't believe in the war cause but go off anyway to get money for college and then they come back complaining and whining.
He wishes he had some school under his belt FIRST, before the military. Because besides civilian opportunities, there are some military jobs which would pay him more if he had at least an Associates.
http://www.progressiveu.org/090204-dont-miss-this-chance
Oh, I didn't know that.