So I had a writing assignment for my Nonviolent Communication class and the question was "Reflect on the Domination Paradigm and write about your experience of this in your life. How does this experience affect you today?" So this is what I wrote:
Just reading the words Domination Paradigm made me let out a big sigh. I think, being a female in this society, and especially being a poor female from a poor farm family, with a very life-on-the-edge past, I have very low status in our society, so I have definitely felt the effects of the Domination Paradigm. I first experienced the Domination Paradigm at home, on the farm. I saw my cousins beat a woodchuck to death with their boots and rocks, a first hand example of domination over an animal. I saw a baby bear in a ditch that a farmer had shot, because he was afraid the bear would mess with his cows. I remember crying when a farmer changed the course of a creek near our house to counteract the erosion the creek was causing; I cried because it seemed wrong to change the course of a natural, wild thing like a creek. All of these are examples of domination of nature and the earth I guess. I’ve also seen lots of examples of domination here in Portland; I work for the Salvation Army, so I see co-workers treating the homeless and women escaping domestic violence in a dominating way; some of my co-workers feel better then those women just because they happen to not be in those situations at the moment. I asked a few co-workers why it seemed that dominating behavior was encouraged; one said “we work for the Salvation Army, its’ right in the name…” She was right; I should have known from the beginning that we’d be expected to “lord over” these ladies. I’ve seen a lot of terrible domination up at OHSU when I used to be an on-call doula up there; unfortunately, OHSU policy seems to be to treat Hispanic women with the greatest disrespect I’ve ever seen. One time in particular, a nurse who had just arrived for a new shift said to a client I’d helped all night with painful contractions “You are a bad mom if you don’t get an epidural…you are hurting your baby..” I sort of doubt she would say something like that to a middle-class white lady, but I could be wrong. It is amazing that they can also do lots of procedures to Hispanic clients without going through a translator to find out if the client wants the procedure done. I also saw a lot of unbelievable and blatant domination of native people while I was in Malawi. I could not believe the debts the British are trying to collect from the Malawians for colonizing their country, something the Malawians I’m sure didn’t want in the first place. Essentially, every person in Malawi is a British slave because the British still owe their land and they grow sugarcane for export to Britain to “pay off their debts,” which are the debts of the infrastructure that the British decided to build in Malawi in the first place! I used to have written on my bathroom wall in purple marker “We still have slaves, we just don’t see them anymore,” which I learned while in Africa…I met those slaves, face to face, and realized I am an agent of domination as much as the next person. I think about these things every time I buy something or turn on a light or whatever; I wonder what slaves in which part of the world grew or made whatever it is I am buying, I wonder how many salmon die throwing themselves against a dam so I can have electricity…I think I’m going to have to eventually leave our culture altogether just to feel ethical. Domination is the key to our civilization.




Really good blog. But what does OHSU stand for? As far as domination, it has sadly been going on for years. Anglo Americans dominated Africans and African Americans because they were lazy, wanted to have power, and wanted to have more insight of the world versus slaves having any insight.The Indians were forced from their land, I think the europeans or anglo americans gave them blankets with small pox (trail of tears) so they could kill some of them. Then to say sorry, they only leave them with the state of Oklahoma when they used to own all of America. Why? Because they felt no one but them should own land and stupid Indians don't know how to run stuff. The Jews sadly were tortured and killed because the Germans felt they were pieces of you know what. Domination is still sadly going on among many races, religion and more.I applaud you for working at Salvation Army.
yes I realize that oppression and domination has been going on for years, and perhaps forever...but it still kills me that it is going on. I feel like we are no more compassionate/humanitarian then we have ever been, and that is the sad thing...you always hope that folks will learn from mistakes made, but instead they just continue to be made...
Love ya,'
Carrot
Carrot says:
"I think I'm going to have to eventually leave our culture altogether just to feel ethical. Domination is the key to our civilization."
Where do you plan on going? I can't think of a place where you can get away from domination. Every culture has it in some form. You may just have to change your reaction to it. Make a positive response from negative feelings.
www.progressiveu.org/blog/americangirlinchina
even joining a bunch of like-minded people who want to "live off the land" and so forth where raised in the domination paradigm and so, there is no doubt going to be some domination even among a group like that. I think I can do better then changing my reaction to it; I can try my best not to dominate anyone else, or anything else, but even then (as we discussed in class today,) if you really do know that something is better for someone else, like a baby wanting to stay at the playground longer even though he is getting frozen, you have to "dominate" that person in that situation in order to protect their health..
Anyway,
Love ya,
Carrot
Being dominant over everything is how we define ourselves as human (a really sad concept I must admit). We've dominated the earth- and thus caused irreversible damage that is only beging to show and in no way letting up. We have dominion over all animal- so we cage them, torture them, and kill them off slowely as we take their land. But its not enough. The need to feel dominant seem to be bred into us. Its so strong that, whenever we meet someone we believe is 'underneath us' we have to show our dominance, most often cruely.
We are a sad sad race. The saddest part? I know we're capable of doing so much better, of doing so much more good. The worst part? We're also capable of doing even worse
when I think about the artist who tied the starving dog to the wall and put food just out of it's reach and starved it even more and called it "art," or Koko the Gorrilla being taught sign language and then signing "I want out" and the fact that she is still a prisoner, or the Holocaust, or the bombing of Japan, or the sweatshops, or the slaughter of the buffalo in hopes that all the Native Peoples left in the United States would starve to death...all of these examples and more make me wonder if it could get any worse...I think we are very good and hiding and covering our atrocities up, but they are numerious and we have done every imaginiable evil to each other and the earth and all the animals...
Read about some of the experiements done on Jews in the concentration camps if you need more examples...they'll give you nightmares...and of course, these experiements gave us great advances in human medicine, but at what cost?
Love ya,
Carrot
We could always do better or worse. If you personally choose to not force your dominance on others, then focus on that and sharing your experiences with others. Why focus on the worst of the worst acts committed by a small number of humans? Each person must choose to do better. So, make the choice and don't worry about past terrifying atrocities. Learn from them and move on.
I don't mean to come on too strong, your post has just elicited this feeling in me.
www.progressiveu.org/blog/americangirlinchina
you are absolutely right. Sometimes I focus (and I don't think I'm the only one,) on mostly negative things that are happening in the world, and when I do this I feel emotionally paralyzed and then I find it very hard to help those in need. This is not good, since the majority of my time and energy is devoted to making a difference...so I definately need to keep myself in a positive and good space. I've found that rewarding myself in small ways; buying small things for myself or just "allowing" myself to do things I enjoy, really help me to stay positive! For a really postive message, read my blog from 4/27/08, called My Church.
Love ya,
Carrot